Dr. Cyriac Abby Philips, a renowned liver specialist and clinician-scientist, also known as ‘The Liver Doctor‘ on social media, has publicly criticized Zoho co-founder and CEO Sridhar Vembu for backing IIT Madras Director Prof. V Kamakoti. Prof. Kamakoti had recently sparked controversy by advocating for the medicinal benefits of cow urine, also known as gomutra.
The Liver Doctor voiced his strong disapproval of the ongoing debate on social media platform X. In a biting critique, he penned, “Hey science illiterate boomer uncle, your so-called Indian traditional medicine, Siddha also encourages fecal transplants. How long will you keep putting your foot in your mouth and speak through your rear, misinform your followers, and make a fool of yourself?”
The Liver Doctor emphasized the responsibility that comes with being a public figure, urging influential individuals to utilize their platform wisely. Specifically addressing Zoho CEO Sridhar Vembu, he stated, “As a man of influence, spread valuable information on how as a community we can progress through science and the scientific method, instead of promoting ancient nonsense and primal therapies and amplifying fools who misinform, like the IIT Madras professor.”
Sridhar Vembu came to the defense of Prof. Kamakoti, arguing that critics of cow urine therapy are unaware of the shifting landscape of scientific research. He pointed out the increasing interest in unconventional treatments, such as fecal transplants and fecal pills, which involve harnessing the beneficial bacteria from healthy individuals, particularly those from pre-industrial societies, to restore gut health.
The Liver Doctor responded to Vembu’s defense of cow urine therapy by highlighting the scientific basis of fecal transplants and sharing links to relevant articles on the subject. He noted that his team has made significant strides in using this method to treat patients suffering from severe alcohol-associated hepatitis. Meanwhile, the controversy surrounding Prof. Kamakoti’s remarks on cow urine continued to simmer. At an event on January 15, Kamakoti stated, “If you would really like to know how fecal transplants have science behind its use, you can read about our work here. We have pioneered this method in salvaging patients dying of severe alcohol-associated hepatitis,” was not said by Kamakoti but “anti-bacterial, anti-fungal, and digestive properties and can be an effective treatment for conditions like Irritable Bowel Syndrome (IBS).” His comments were met with criticism, with many labeling them as pseudoscientific and questioning the logic behind such claims.
The Liver Doctor countered with a clear and direct statement, “Urine therapy has no such known benefits and there is no science behind promoting its use. Educate yourself. And stop with the Strawman fallacies,” emphasizing the lack of scientific evidence supporting the benefits of urine therapy and urging those promoting it to educate themselves on the matter.
ⓘ LAFFAZ is not responsible for the content of external sites. Users are required to read and abide by our Terms of Service.
